I’ve spent the last several months carrying around a weight that I haven’t wanted to name. It’s the kind of weight that sits in the pit of your stomach when you know a decision is coming, but saying it out loud somehow makes it real. We have made the decision to let Joy go next week, and while I know in my heart it is the kindest thing we can do for her, that knowledge hasn’t quieted the anxiety. If anything, it has made it louder.
Everyone says you’ll know when it’s time, but I don’t think that’s entirely true. There isn’t a flashing sign that suddenly appears or a single moment where everything changes. Instead, it happens so gradually that you find yourself questioning every day. She still gets excited when she sees us. She still demands the cheese tax. She still wants to be as close to Tim and me as she can possibly get. But then there are the other moments. The hesitation to be up on the bed or couch that are happening more often. The hips that no longer wants to cooperate. The accidents that seem to embarrass her more than they inconvenience us. The breathing that has become more labored. The off-putting smell on her fur because she can no longer keep herself as clean as she once did. None of those moments, by themselves, feel like enough. Together, though, they paint a picture that I’ve been trying desperately not to look at.
The hardest part of loving a dog is that we eventually have to decide whether we’re holding on because they’re still living, or because we aren’t ready to imagine life without them. Dogs will endure far more discomfort than we ever realize if it means staying by our side. They don’t complain. They don’t tell us they’re tired. They simply keep choosing us, even when their little bodies are failing them. That means the responsibility falls to us, and I think that’s one of the cruelest gifts they leave behind.
Joy has another layer to her story that makes this goodbye even harder. She wasn’t just my dog. She was Fred’s dog.
When I look through old pictures of her, I’m reminded that she has quietly carried pieces of my entire adult life. One of my favorite photos is from Christmas, with Fred wrapped in strands of colorful lights while Joy sat happily in his lap looking like she had somehow orchestrated the whole thing. It’s such a silly picture, but it captures everything about those years. Joy adored him, and he adored her. She was there for ordinary evenings, Christmas mornings, road trips, and all the little moments that never seemed important enough to photograph because we assumed there would be thousands more.
When Fred died, Joy lost someone too.
She couldn’t understand why he never came home – spent days sitting in his chair with his blanket when he was gone – but somehow she stayed beside me while I learned how to navigate a life I never expected to have. Through every hard day, every new beginning, every tear, and eventually every smile, Joy remained. Somewhere along the way, she learned to love Tim too. He never tried to replace what she had lost. He simply loved her where she was, and she made room for him in that tiny heart. Watching that happen has been one of the sweetest reminders that love doesn’t erase what came before. It simply grows large enough to hold someone new.
As we’ve talked about this decision over the last few days, I keep thinking about our upcoming trip to Europe. For weeks I found myself praying that she wouldn’t leave while we were gone because I couldn’t bear the thought of her final moments happening without us. In some ways, I think she made the decision for us. She has been telling us, gently and faithfully, that she’s getting tired. The clinginess. The falls. The slowing down. The quiet surrender of all the little things that once came so easily. Maybe loving her now means listening instead of asking her to keep trying.
There is something profoundly unfair about the fact that dogs give us every single piece of themselves, yet their lives are so much shorter than ours. Almost sixteen years somehow feels both incredibly long and impossibly short. She’s been here through two marriages, through unimaginable grief, through healing I never thought possible, through new beginnings, new homes, new routines, and all the ordinary Tuesdays in between. She isn’t just losing her life next week. An entire chapter of mine is quietly coming to an end with her.
I know there will be people who say, “She had a good, long life,” and they’re right. She did. But that doesn’t make saying goodbye easier. Gratitude and grief have never canceled each other out. In fact, I think the deeper the gratitude, the deeper the grief becomes. We don’t mourn because we were cheated. We mourn because we were blessed.
So next week, my heart will break a little more. It will be another goodbye to another beloved fur baby. It will stir up memories I haven’t visited in years. It will remind me of the husband who first placed this little dog into my life, and it will remind me how fortunate I have been to have another man willing to love her just as fiercely. Most of all, it will remind me that the greatest promise we make to our pets isn’t that we’ll keep them alive forever. It’s that we’ll protect them, even when protecting them means accepting heartbreak ourselves.
Joy has spent nearly sixteen years giving us everything she had. Next week, our final act of love will be giving her peace. And as impossible as that feels today, I hope that someday, when the ache isn’t quite so sharp, I’ll be able to look back and know that this wasn’t the day we stopped loving her. It was the day we loved her enough to let her go.
My heart goes out to you all! 💔